Breadth Thrust Indicator – Can it Forecast Major Market Bottoms?

May 9, 2019

Written by:
Al Hill


Breadth Thrust Indicator Overview

Dr. Marty Zweig, a Wallstreet legend is the creator of the indicator.

The Breadth Thrust indicator measures market breadth by dividing the advancing issues by the sum of the advancing and declining issues on the New York Stock Exchange. The output of this calculation is a ratio is then calculated over the last 10 periods to give you the value of the indicator.

Breadth Thrust Indicator Formula

#Advancing Securities/ (#Advancing Securities + #Declining Securities)

Primary Methods

The indicator can work as an intermediate timing tool and it can also identify long-term buying opportunities.

Why is the Indicator So Popular?

Dr. Zweig was known for combining both fundamentals and technical analysis when making market forecasts. Zweig used the Breadth Thrust indicator to pinpoint major shifts from a bear to a bull market.

The Trigger

The Breadth Thurst indicator is oversold below 40 and overbought above 61.5. When the indicator is able to move from 40 to 61.5 in less than 10 days, this is a sign of a major shift to the long side in the market.

This bullish signal is so popular, it is covered by major financial news outlets, in the same manner, these shows report when the market breaks the 200-day moving average.

How Does the Breadth Thrust Indicator work?

Unlike other oscillators, the indicator focuses on the rate of change from oversold to overbought.

Zweig theorized that a rapid rate of change of money from bear to bull increases the likelihood stocks will push higher over the long-term.

1984 to 2009

There were no signals for 25 years (1984 through 2009). This is undeniable proof this signal is for long-term moves.

Do you think you can wait that long for a trade signal? Make sure you set up an auto alert. Who can remember to look for a signal every day for 25 years!

The signal finally showed up after the 2008 global financial crisis and the market hasn’t looked back since.

The chart below shows this major market bottom that was called by the Breadth Thrust indicator.

Zweig Breadth Thrust Indicator gives a major signal in March 2009

Zweig Breadth Thrust Indicator gives a major signal in March 2009

The indicator made the move in just eight trading days.

Another Major Buying Opportunity Example

In addition to identifying market bottoms, the indicator can also inform investors when they should stay long in the market.

During October 2015, the markets were in a state of uncertainty with the China slowdown and the possible tightening from the U.S. Federal Reserve. Some investors viewed this data as a reason for trimming their exposure to equity markets.

However, the Breadth Thrust indicator was giving a different trade signal.

The chart below shows the period between September and October 2015. As the market put in a double bottom, the indicator also gave a buy signal.

Zweig Breadth Thrust Indicator, September 2015

Zweig Breadth Thrust Indicator, September 2015

Within a span of 8 trading days, the indicator shot up from below 0.40 to above 0.615 – signaling a buy. The S&P500 rallied nearly 4% before stalling near the 2100 level.

How To Use the Market Breadth Indicator to Validate Trend Strength

The market breadth indicator can also help validate trends and turning points in the market.

To better understand how to use the market breadth indicator as a confirmation tool, let’s look at an example.

Below is the S&P500 with an overlay of the 50 and 200 period moving averages.

Zweig Breadth Thrust indicator as a market confirmation tool

Zweig Breadth Thrust indicator as a market confirmation tool

Two Trade Signals

First, when the market slips below the 50-day moving average, you wait for the Breadth Thrust indicator to trend up again to validate the buy signal.

Next, you can identify support on the chart and then look to the indicator to validate if the support will hold. Please see in the above chart how previous resistance later turns to support.

The indicator then gives a major buy signal after briefly penetrating the level.

Should Day Traders Use the Signal

Since the indicator has such a long-term perspective, day traders should not obsess over watching the ratio.

However, once day traders see the sign of strength, they will want to utilize more of their long strategies as there are greater opportunities on the bull side.

In Summary

Between 1945 and 2000, the indicator signaled fourteen buy signals.

The average gain for each signal was 24%!

The question now is will the indicator continue to provide accurate forecasts for turning points in the market and will the average gain continue at these levels?

Tags: Breadth Indicators

Breadth Indicators

Bull Bear Ratio and How You Can Use this Indicator

Bull bear ratio is a technical indicator that is not quite technical. Unlike most other indicators you might have come across, the bull bear ratio is quite different. Most traders tend to get lost in...

Trend Indicators

Leading vs. Lagging Indicators – Who is the Clear Winner

Indicators are at the heart of trading if you prefer technical analysis as your method of choice. These indicators are relevant whether you day trade or swing trade. If you think of it, the entire...

Trend Indicators

How to Use the Aroon Indicator in Both Trending and Range Markets

The Aroon indicator was developed by Tushar Chande, who also created the Chande Momentum Oscillator indicator and the Qstick. When it comes to day trading, strategies based on the Aroon indicator are...